Register of Beneficial Owners: Luxembourg Cour de cassation specifies criteria for criminal conviction

3 mn

In the context of enhanced checks of compliance with obligations concerning the Register of Beneficial Owners (RBE), the 12 November 2026 decision of Luxembourg’s highest court , the Cour de cassation, has specified the criteria for a criminal conviction due to failure to fulfil RBE obligations. The Court distinguished negligence from intentional omission and reiterated the criteria for engaging the criminal liability of a legal entity.

Negligence is not enough to amount to an omission “knowingly” committed

Since the reform of 23 January 2025, which entered into force on 1 February 2025, Article 20, paragraph (1) of the RBE Law sanctions registered entities that “knowingly” fail to apply to register information relating to their beneficial owners and amendments thereof, within the statutory time limits.


The Cour de cassation (Court) confirmed that this offence requires mens rea (dol général), namely the intention to carry out the culpable omission and awareness of having committed the offence. It does not require specific intent (dol spécial), such as a specific intention to defraud.


However, the required intent must be characterised in concrete terms. In this case, the appeal judges had focused notably on the managers’ knowledge of the statutory obligations, the recourse to a service provider deemed to have been too late and the allegedly insufficient steps taken to ensure compliance with time limits.


The Court rejected this reasoning. These findings described instances of negligence without seeking the elements that make it possible to establish an intention to carry out the alleged omission with full knowledge of the facts. Therefore, in this case, knowledge of the obligations and a lack of diligence were not enough to justify conviction.

Criminal liability of legal entities cannot be presumed

In addition to reiterating the criteria in Article 34 of the Criminal Code, the decision’s value is above all in the rigorous standard that it demands of trial judges when they hold a legal entity criminally liable for failure to comply with RBE obligations. It is not enough to identify a breach and deduce the entity’s guilt from there. Instead, the trial judges must give a concrete explanation of how the conditions for imputing the offence to the entity are satisfied.


In addition, they must identify and refer in their decision to the relevant natural person under Article 34 of the Criminal Code through whom the constituent elements of the offence are established. The trial judges must also specify in what way the offence was committed in the name of and in the interest of the legal entity. These elements must be the subject of explicit findings and cannot remain implicit in the reasoning that underpins the conviction.


In this case, by censuring the appeal judges for not having carried out this analysis and the necessary findings regarding Article 21, paragraph (1) of the RBE Law, the Court has given this requirement a practical scope. The courts of first instance must now pay particular attention to identifying the facts and the justification for imputing them to the legal entity. Therefore, the result of the decision is less a new principle of liability and more a requirement for effective and explicit application of the statutory criteria for this liability.

What are the practical takeaways?

This decision does not exempt entities from complying with their RBE obligations. It does, however, impose a rigorous assessment of the criteria for a criminal conviction: identifying the intent required for the omission to declare and establishing the criteria for imputing the offence to the legal entity on a practical level.


However, the decision does not answer the question of whether natural persons, especially senior executives and managers, can be personally convicted for failures related to RBE obligations. Therefore, the need to identify a natural person to engage the liability of the legal entity must not be confused with a decision on their personal criminal liability.

Compliance checklist to follow

Regardless of the clarifications provided by this decision, registered entities should, as part of monitoring their RBE obligations:

  • verify the accuracy and currency of declared information, and ensure that it is kept at the registered office
  • formalise internal responsibilities and monitoring of deadlines, including when a service provider is involved
  • keep a record of instructions, reminders and compliance activities undertaken
  • not blindly trust external service providers and verify that registrations have been carried out
  • request support from the very first contact with the authorities in the event of an audit or prosecution proceedings
Eine Person gleitet mit einem leuchtend orangefarbenen und roten Flügel über den nebligen Bergen, darunter der ikonische Half Dome, unter einem klaren blauen Himmel.

How can we help?

In this context, our Business Crime and Banking & Financial Services teams, including the RBE team, are here to analyse your situation, support you in your compliance process and protect your interests.